Sarah's Christmas Cookies

Note: the site is currently being updated for the 2017 season. Please come back later!

For the 2017 Christmas Season, Sarah has once again baked thirty-six different varieties of cookies, biscotti, and candies. This year, she decided to try four new cookies to go along with lots of old favorites!

Each year we try to improve the Cookie Rating System™ and, yes, Sarah really does use it to help her decide which cookies to bake next year. If your favorite isn't on this year's list, it may be because you didn't vote for it last year! We know it's tempting, but please only vote once for each cookie! If you vote more than once for your favorite, somebody else with more time and patience than you might try to beat you at your own game!

Don't Forget: You can vote for Sarah to bring a Retired Cookie out of retirement!

The 2017 Collection

Please vote no more than once for each cookie!

cookie_name: almond_toffee_biscotti
cookie name: almond_toffee_biscotti
#votes: 6
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: almond_toffee_triangles
cookie name: almond_toffee_triangles
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: alsatian_christmas_cookies
cookie name: alsatian_christmas_cookies
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: apple_cider_caramels
cookie name: apple_cider_caramels
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: browned_butter_maple_sandwiches
cookie name: browned_butter_maple_sandwiches
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: cherry_almond_biscotti
cookie name: cherry_almond_biscotti
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: cherry_covered_chocolates
cookie name: cherry_covered_chocolates
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_almond_hazelnut_cookies
cookie name: chocolate_almond_hazelnut_cookies
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_cherry_crackles
cookie name: chocolate_cherry_crackles
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_coconut_marshmallows
cookie name: chocolate_coconut_marshmallows
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_dotted_orange_biscotti
cookie name: chocolate_dotted_orange_biscotti
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_mint_sandwich_cookies
cookie name: chocolate_mint_sandwich_cookies
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_palmiers
cookie name: chocolate_palmiers
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_peanut_butter_patties
cookie name: chocolate_peanut_butter_patties
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: chocolate_phantoms
cookie name: chocolate_phantoms
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: christmas_biscotti
cookie name: christmas_biscotti
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: coconut_chocolate_slices
cookie name: coconut_chocolate_slices
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: coconut_macaroons
cookie name: coconut_macaroons
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: cran_orange_slices
cookie name: cran_orange_slices
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: double_chocolate_biscotti
cookie name: double_chocolate_biscotti
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: gingerbread
cookie name: gingerbread
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: italian_sprinkle_cookies
cookie name: italian_sprinkle_cookies
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: lebkuchen
cookie name: lebkuchen
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: lemon_snowdrops
cookie name: lemon_snowdrops
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: maple_pecan_biscotti
cookie name: maple_pecan_biscotti
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: mincemeat_pockets
cookie name: mincemeat_pockets
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: mint_capped_brownie_cups
cookie name: mint_capped_brownie_cups
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: nuremberger
cookie name: nuremberger
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: peppermint_marshmallows
cookie name: peppermint_marshmallows
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: petticoat_tails
cookie name: petticoat_tails
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: pistachio_jam_cookies
cookie name: pistachio_jam_cookies
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: puerto_rican_rum_cookies
cookie name: puerto_rican_rum_cookies
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: rainbow_cookies
cookie name: rainbow_cookies
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: scottish_shortbread
cookie name: scottish_shortbread
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: soft_caramels
cookie name: soft_caramels
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote: cookie_name: viennese_shortbread
cookie name: viennese_shortbread
#votes:
star w: 0
new vote:
Want to see the background image?